Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Cheesecake

My mixer stopped mid-beat one afternoon, and I realized I'd been creaming the cream cheese for nearly ten minutes, lost in thought about what dessert could possibly follow a heavy dinner party. That's when I spotted the sleeve of Nutter Butters I'd hidden from myself on the top shelf. The idea hit me all at once: a cheesecake that tasted like childhood, but felt like celebration. I pulled out my springform pan and didn't stop until the kitchen smelled like toasted peanut butter and sugar.

I made this for my brother's birthday because he's never met a peanut butter dessert he didn't love. When I set it on the table, his face lit up like he was eight years old again, and he asked if he could skip dinner and go straight to cake. We didn't let him, but we all understood the temptation. That cheesecake disappeared faster than anything I'd ever baked, and I found myself writing down the recipe on a napkin for three different people before the night ended.

Ingredients

• Nutter Butter cookies: These create a crust that's sweet, salty, and tastes like nostalgia, and crushing them by hand in a zip-top bag is oddly satisfying.
• Unsalted butter: Melted butter binds the cookie crumbs together and adds richness without making the crust greasy.
• Cream cheese: The backbone of the filling, and it must be fully softened or you'll end up with lumps no amount of mixing can fix.
• Granulated sugar: Sweetens the filling just enough to balance the tang of the cream cheese and the salt in the peanut butter.
• Vanilla extract: A little vanilla deepens the flavor and makes everything taste more rounded and intentional.
• Eggs: They give the cheesecake structure, but overbeating them will make it puff up and crack, so go gently.
• Creamy peanut butter: Use the kind that's smooth and spreadable, not the natural stuff that separates, or the texture won't be right.
• Heavy whipping cream: Whipped fresh, it turns into the perfect cloud to top each slice.
• Powdered sugar: Sweetens the whipped cream without making it gritty.
• Chopped peanuts: Optional, but they add a welcome crunch and make the whole thing look finished.

Instructions

Prep the pan:

Preheat your oven to 325°F and grease your springform pan, then line the bottom with parchment paper so the crust releases cleanly. This small step saves you so much frustration later.

Make the crust:

Toss the crushed cookies with melted butter until the mixture looks like damp sand, then press it firmly into the bottom of the pan. Bake it for 10 minutes to set, then let it cool while you make the filling.

Beat the cream cheese:

Whip the softened cream cheese and sugar together until it's completely smooth and lighter in color, about 2 to 3 minutes. Scrape down the sides of the bowl so nothing gets left behind.

Add peanut butter and vanilla:

Mix in the peanut butter and vanilla until the filling is uniform and silky. The smell at this stage is almost enough to make you want to eat it straight from the bowl.

Incorporate the eggs:

Add the eggs one at a time on low speed, mixing just until each one disappears into the batter. Overmixing here introduces air that can cause cracks.

Pour and smooth:

Pour the filling over the cooled crust and use a spatula to smooth the top into an even layer. Tap the pan gently on the counter to release any air bubbles.

Bake low and slow:

Bake for 50 to 60 minutes until the edges are set but the center still has a slight jiggle when you shake the pan. It will firm up as it cools, so don't wait for it to look completely solid.

Cool in the oven:

Turn off the heat, crack the oven door, and let the cheesecake sit inside for an hour. This gradual cooldown is the secret to avoiding cracks on the surface.

Chill completely:

Transfer the cheesecake to the fridge and let it chill for at least 4 hours, though overnight is even better. Patience here pays off in texture and flavor.

Whip the topping:

Beat the heavy cream with powdered sugar until stiff peaks form, then spread it generously over the chilled cheesecake. It should look like soft, sweet clouds.

Garnish and serve:

Sprinkle chopped peanuts and tuck a few whole Nutter Butters around the edge for decoration. Slice with a warm, clean knife for the neatest cuts.

Pin it

The first time I served this, someone asked if I'd ordered it from a fancy bakery. I didn't correct them right away because I wanted to enjoy the compliment, but eventually I admitted it all started with a cookie I used to trade for in my school lunchbox. That's the magic of this dessert, it tastes elevated and indulgent, but it's rooted in something simple and familiar. It makes people happy in a way that feels both surprising and comforting at the same time.

Making It Ahead

This cheesecake actually improves after a night in the fridge because the flavors meld and the texture becomes even creamier. I almost always make it the day before I need it, and I keep the whipped cream separate until just before serving so it stays fluffy. You can even freeze the whole thing without the topping for up to a month, then thaw it overnight in the fridge and add fresh whipped cream when you're ready. It's one of those rare desserts that gets better with time instead of suffering from it.

Serving Suggestions

I like to serve this with a drizzle of warm chocolate ganache or salted caramel sauce, both of which make the peanut butter flavor sing even louder. Some people love it with a handful of fresh berries on the side for a tart contrast, though I'm usually too busy enjoying it as-is. A cup of strong coffee or a glass of cold milk are both perfect companions. If you're feeling extra, a scoop of vanilla ice cream on the side turns each slice into a full-on event.

Storage and Leftovers

Keep any leftover cheesecake covered tightly in the fridge, where it will stay fresh for up to five days. The whipped cream may deflate slightly after a day or two, but the flavor remains just as good. I've been known to eat a cold slice straight from the fridge at breakfast, and I'm not ashamed to admit it tasted wonderful.

• Always cover the cheesecake with plastic wrap or foil to keep it from absorbing other fridge smells.
• If you freeze it, let it thaw slowly in the fridge rather than on the counter.
• For the cleanest slices, wipe your knife between cuts and run it under hot water first.

Pin it

This cheesecake has become my answer to every potluck, birthday, and random Tuesday when I need something sweet to look forward to. It's rich, it's nostalgic, and it never fails to make people smile.

Recipe FAQs

→ How long should I chill the cheesecake before serving?

Refrigerate the cheesecake for at least 4 hours, though overnight chilling yields the best results. This allows the filling to set completely and develop deeper flavors. The rest time is crucial for achieving that perfectly sliceable texture.

→ Can I prevent cracks from forming on the cheesecake surface?

Baking in a water bath helps create a creamier texture and reduces cracking. Additionally, letting the cheesecake cool gradually in the oven with the door cracked for one hour prevents thermal shock. Avoid over-mixing the eggs and follow the gentle cooling process.

→ What's the best way to crush Nutter Butter cookies for the crust?

Place the cookies in a sealed plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin, or pulse in a food processor until fine crumbs form. The texture should resemble wet sand when mixed with melted butter, ensuring it presses evenly into the springform pan.

→ Can I make this dessert ahead of time?

Absolutely! Making this cheesecake a day ahead actually improves the flavor profile. The filling sets more firmly, and the peanut butter taste intensifies. Store in the refrigerator covered, and add whipped cream and garnishes just before serving for optimal freshness.

→ How do I know when the cheesecake is done baking?

The cheesecake is ready when the edges appear set and firm while the center retains a slight jiggle, similar to gelatin. This residual heat will continue cooking the center as it cools. Avoid baking until completely firm, as this results in a dry texture.

→ Can I substitute natural peanut butter for creamy peanut butter?

While natural peanut butter works, creamy commercial peanut butter provides better consistency due to its stable emulsion. Natural varieties may cause slight separation or affect the smooth texture. For best results, use a standard creamy peanut butter without added oils or sweeteners.